Countdown to Halloween: October 11, 2011
Source: Netflix Instant Play
Wow. I expected nothing from this movie, and I was completely shocked. Of course I thought at the beginning that it was going to be a Saw ripoff, but it totally wasn’t. Sure, maybe the story was mostly Sawish, but the execution wasn’t. It was more clean and to the point. It’s the difference between John and the killer in this movie. John didn’t want people to change… he just wanted to torture them and let them die knowing why. The killer here gives them a chance to figure it out, and change if they manage to leave alive. In that way, I think it was a little bit more harrowing. I mean, in Saw you know those people were going to die. Here, you kept wondering who would finally give that last piece of information, and which ones would be left. This was clean, fast, and to the point.
Most of the complaints I’ve read about this movie are about the ending. But I wonder if that’s just because people want everything tied up in a nice neat package and handed to them. People don’t want to have to use their imagination. I think the way it ended, while frustrating, was along the same lines as the rest of the movie: you need to figure it out. Of course there isn’t any more evidence or anything to know for sure, but there’s a shot in the last minute or so of the movie that if you paid attention, would bother the crud out of you once the ending credits started rolling. It basically changes the ending completely, depending on what actually happened in that one shot. I wish I could say it, because it’s immensely frustrating, but if I did, it would ruin the whole movie. Spoilers in this kind of film are the worst. Intricate weavings of lives, actions, and consequences hang in a very delicate balance. So while the ending does frustrate me, I don’t think it was a case of “the writer just didn’t know how to end it” as one Netflix reviewer put it. I think that if someone doesn’t like the ending, it’s because they’re not willing to accept that not everything gets tied up in a neat little package and handed to you.